Marcie Alana ([info]mrciealana) wrote,
@ 2002-05-14 16:22:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Closets
I've been meaning to write this for a long time. It's the reason my journal exists in the first place. You see, I've been in the closet. Reading through my journal, that might be a little hard to believe, but it's true.

I've admitted to being bisexual (and preferring women). I've admitted to being polyamorous. I've admitted to a less than stellar childhood, and I've probably even admitted to having a few issues around co-dependence and abandonment. The thing I haven't talked about in my journal is that I am a transsexual. Or was. I'm not really clear on that. I mean, I've had surgery and all, and have been living a gender-harmonious life for a few years now. I don't have any gender issues left, so am I?

Well, I may not have issues with my gender, but it's been my experience that a lot of other people do. I knew this wouldn't be easy, and it hasn't been. In my day to day life, it's not much of an issue though. I am a woman, I look like any other woman, and there's nothing about me that gives folks pause -- I mean, other than being six feet tall. ("Mommy, look at that tall lady!" "Did you play basketball in college?")

But when it comes to my personal life, things are a bit different. A lot of transsexuals lose their family or jobs in coming out. I was blessed, and managed to avoid all that. I even managed to keep most of my friends, not that there were many to begin with. But when it comes to more intimate interactions, all bets are off.

I'm not sure what it is about men, but I'd swear they see a transsexual as an affront to their masculinity -- especially if they've had amorous thoughts. People like me are assaulted a lot more frequently as a result. I just short circuit the whole thing by admitting my "gender history" at the first opportunity. Sometimes men are polite and say "thank you for being honest" before they run off. Sometimes they're not polite at all. But generally, the ones I have to worry about are the ones who don't run off -- most of them seem to have some sort of weird kink around transsexuals. Generally they disappear when they realize I'm pretty much just like any other girl. Nothing special.

Women are generally worse. I've been on the edge of the women's community in San Francisco for years. I've had several women get "warned" about me, and at least one was pressured into breaking things off by her friends. I pretty much gave up on the whole "community" thing. It just wasn't working. I guess it's not surprising that people who identify as bisexual seem to have the fewest problems with me. Gender must be less of an issue for them.

All this sounds like I'm lonely and complaining. I'm not lonely, I have two wonderful girlfriends and I occasionally see an old male friend as well (I was one of his groomsmen years ago). I am complaining though. It's not pleasant to be insulted, and even assaulted for being who you are. The further I get from the west coast, the more I have to worry for my safety (though I understand there are areas that are pretty accepting on the east coast too). Fortunately, the further I get from home, the less likely it is that anyone will figure out that I'm different.

Sometimes I think about moving a long way from here where no one knows me, and the only reason they even know the word "transsexual" is the Jerry Springer show. Move and just not say anything about it. Lead a quiet life, and just hope this all goes away.

But I can't. I'm too honest. I also have a bit of an ego. I have made a success of my life in spite of it all, and I think people need a good example. When they think of transsexuals, I'd prefer they think of someone like me -- a (nearly) middle aged suburban home owner, and not a dolled up "she-male" working in the sex trade.

I'm not going away; is acceptance too much to ask?



(15 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]pucks
2002-05-14 04:28 pm UTC (link)
Not at all!

(Reply to this)

ordinary
[info]dgrsshppr
2002-05-15 12:32 am UTC (link)
It's hard for me to remember why this is supposed to be such a big deal...

When we first met, I admit, I spent a lot of time researching transsexuality and thinking about it. Mostly, this was a process of examining my preconcieved ideas--not so much about transsexuals, but about gender itself. What does it mean? Why is it important? As I told one of my friends, "None of my assumptions work. I have to really pay attention, and get to know her as she is." My friend said, "But shouldn't we do that with everyone?"

The thing that's interesting about your gendered behavior is what is missing, rather than what is present. You have managed to escape the worst of both masculine and feminine programming. You know your feelings intimately, and you have no doubt of your right to them.

As is the case with many people who have had solitary paths and hard choices, you know yourself, and are fully present in your own life. This is the most interesting thing about you, the one that invites the deepest exploration, the one that yields the greatest gifts.

I suppose gender is important for some reason. I am certainly more comfortable in my own decidedly unfeminine skin since knowing you, because you have made it safe for me to be myself. But it seems so ordinary now, this confidence and ease with you, with myself--with anyone else, at that. Scratch almost anybody, and you'll find something transgendered.

And that is the root of the prejudice you've seen--each person's fear, not of you, but of hirself.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: ordinary
[info]mrciealana
2002-05-15 09:51 am UTC (link)
Gods, you make me sound like a saint! (I'm supposed to say thank you, yes?) ;)

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: ordinary
[info]dgrsshppr
2002-05-16 02:50 am UTC (link)
Saint? Irrelevent. You have a very strong character, a strong sense of ethics. You have a keen intuition, an insight you can rarely articulate fully but which is often proved incisive over time. You make errors more often in reaction than in perception. You have your fears, insecurities. You are complex. You take a long view. You are prepared for the worst, yet act on faith. You behave in accordance with your values, despite the expectation that no-one will notice or understand. You make your own rules and follow them. You know your thoughts and your feelings, but are ruled by neither. Your vision is clear.

The list of people whose opinions I respect is short. My perceptions are not unreasonably distorted by love--I've watched you for some time now, and have data to check against. Yes, you are extraordinary, but not so much for the most obvious reason. Gender is only one small lense through which you may be seen. To see you, I look beyond the obvious, and pay attention. xo

(Reply to this) (Parent)

Not too many skeletons in there...
[info]analogrto
2002-05-15 06:56 am UTC (link)
You know we've known about your background for a long time. T has rejected a lot of the ideas she had crammed into her head growing up, in good because of you and your friendship. We came close to having a relationship--I don't think that had anything to do with your history. I think it had more to do with your personality and energy. We still haven't disappeared after that ended.

Acceptance? If you want to see what the future will hold, look to the children. I know two that abdolutely adore you; they were asking last night if we could do dinner with you more instead of you doing lunch with T and I. I guess they care about you as much as we do.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: Not too many skeletons in there...
[info]mrciealana
2002-05-15 09:53 am UTC (link)
*smile* That's absolutely delightful! And yes, we can manage dinner, I think.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]femery
2002-05-15 12:24 pm UTC (link)
Hi Marcie!

I have known you for a long while now, and have always wished to get to know you even better! I found you attractive as a male, but even more attractive as a female.

I think its because you have just been a very genuine person ... the same inside beauty shined out of you before as a man; and the same inside beauty shines out of you now as a woman.

As for the woman's community, the poly community, and the het communities .... I too, as a bisexual woman, have hit many an uncomfortable moment. The gay women are suspicious; the poly community thinks mostly of the safety of the "primary partner, just wants to play, and often forgets to create safety for the secondaries; and the het community has many activities they seem always to be biased about.

So ..... I wonder, if perhaps being bisexual and/or transexual just might be a different sexual minority all together. The Third Sexuality!

Who's to say?

As for you my pretty ..... one of the things I have always admired most about you is your willingness to share your thoughts, and your honesty!

Keep up the questioning, and the good work.

Diane

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]mrciealana
2002-05-15 01:20 pm UTC (link)
*smile* Thanks hon. Well, there's surely no time like the present to get to know me ;)

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]femery
2002-05-15 03:09 pm UTC (link)
I'd like that!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]raaven
2002-05-16 08:52 am UTC (link)
A bunch of jumbled thoughts from a sleep-deprived brain:
(in no particular order)

-anyone who decides not to accept you based on something that has so little to do with who you are, can go suck eggs. that kind of prejudice is stupidity incarnate.

-i'm curious, now...what was the impetus to come out of the closet at this particular moment? or, rather...why was it something you felt you had to keep in for so long (here, i mean.), and what allowed you to release it?

-in real life (as opposed to livejournal, for instance), i've found that community is not something you can join, but rather it is something you must create yourself. each individual has their own community, and while they sometimes overlap, they are never identical.

-it can definitely be hard on 'we-who-fit-no-mainstreams' to move from the west coast and/or southwest to any other place in the states. i lived in arizona for ten years; i got used to a certain degree of sensitivity (or at least awareness) from people around me that i just don't have here in nyc. it's weird & oftimes discomfiting. sometimes even frightening (though i go from frightened to annoyed in under 60 seconds, usually).

-as long as you have acceptance from your loved ones and friends and most importantly, yourself (and it seems to me that you do - on all counts), then the other folks will either fall into line or fall by the wayside. let them sort themselves out.

::hugs::

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]raaven
2002-05-16 08:52 am UTC (link)
i'll just add that i really hope the above comes across coherently...and i'm going to go sleep now. really. :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]mrciealana
2002-05-16 10:13 am UTC (link)
*smile* I'm not going to respond to all of this, but I think a couple things deserve answers:

-i'm curious, now...what was the impetus to come out of the closet at this particular moment? or, rather...why was it something you felt you had to keep in for so long (here, i mean.), and what allowed you to release it?

While I was in transition, I spent a lot of time doing support work with other transsexuals. We tend to have a number of problems that come along with the whole gender issue, including serious depression. I had a web site set up that detailed some of the surgical work I'd gone through, so that others would know what was possible, and perhaps get a bit of hope from it.

But in doing all of this, I discovered that much too much of my interactions with others became about being transsexual, and that wasn't what I wanted from life. Especially with friends and intimates. This is not to say I've stopped supporting others like me and offering help, I still lurk on at least one mailing list and speak up when folks have questions, and that web site is still out there (though unmaintained) for those who need it.

So I wanted to start a journal that was about me. What I do and what I think. I wanted a place to point people who wanted to get to know me. I started this journal on my own web page near the beginning of the year, and I still reflect a lot of what I write here on that site. My plan was to write for a few months and then place this revelation in the middle. of it all. I don't want to hide, but I want people to know there's a lot more to me than gender.

-in real life (as opposed to livejournal, for instance), i've found that community is not something you can join, but rather it is something you must create yourself. each individual has their own community, and while they sometimes overlap, they are never identical.

I didn't mean to give the impression that I'm community-less. I'm pretty well known in the San Francisco bay area kink and poly communities. Those places are home for me, and there are many accepting individuals there., and there are always people who want to get to know me better. Perhaps I make some of my own troubles in that respect. I'm a loner and outsider in many ways.

-it can definitely be hard on 'we-who-fit-no-mainstreams' to move from the west coast and/or southwest to any other place in the states. i lived in arizona for ten years; i got used to a certain degree of sensitivity (or at least awareness) from people around me that i just don't have here in nyc. it's weird & oftimes discomfiting. sometimes even frightening (though i go from frightened to annoyed in under 60 seconds, usually).

I spent a year working in Phoneix, and 5 in New Mexico, and another 7 or so in southern Nevada. I know the southwest. That was some time ago though. Generally folks in those areas aren't aware enough of transsexuals that they're going to guess, but if they did, I wouldn't expect it to go well for me.

My day to day life is pretty painless with respect to all of this. It's primarily when new people enter (or contemplate enterying) my life that troubles occur. I was uncomfortable traveling away from the bay area until I actually did a little bit of it. People see what I am not what I was. But when someone finds out (usually by word of mouth), and spreads the word -- which happens often enough, things get unpleasant.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]raaven
2002-05-16 10:24 pm UTC (link)
So I wanted to start a journal that was about me. What I do and what I think. I wanted a place to point people who wanted to get to know me. I started this journal on my own web page near the beginning of the year, and I still reflect a lot of what I write here on that site. My plan was to write for a few months and then place this revelation in the middle. of it all. I don't want to hide, but I want people to know there's a lot more to me than gender.

There certainly is. :) I, for one, am very glad you decided to journal here...I might not have ever run across you, otherwise.

Perhaps I make some of my own troubles in that respect. I'm a loner and outsider in many ways.

Um...yeah...no, no...I don't know what you mean, why do you ask? *grin*

I spent a year working in Phoneix, and 5 in New Mexico, and another 7 or so in southern Nevada. I know the southwest. That was some time ago though. Generally folks in those areas aren't aware enough of transsexuals that they're going to guess, but if they did, I wouldn't expect it to go well for me.

I'm sorry to hear that. My experience was almost entirely in Tucson, and it seemed in many ways an open and supportive place. Mind, I'm not dealing with the same issues you are, but still. New York is very...uptight in comparison.

My day to day life is pretty painless with respect to all of this. It's primarily when new people enter (or contemplate enterying) my life that troubles occur. I was uncomfortable traveling away from the bay area until I actually did a little bit of it. People see what I am not what I was. But when someone finds out (usually by word of mouth), and spreads the word -- which happens often enough, things get unpleasant.

Sometimes I think people just suck. I hope you're always surrounded by those who don't. Or who do, but in a good way. :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)

i explain being tall...
[info]goodmoonrising
2002-06-13 02:24 pm UTC (link)
with "i'm from nebraska." that tends to shut people up.

and i played lacrosse in college. heh. well, after i transferred because my first school flipped a bitch at the idea of transitioning. when i used to hang out on the clone internet-tranny boards, i'd send them the picture of me in my goalie gear, and they'd just be pissy.

of course, big girls make good goalies. you can always say that, too.

oh yeah: middle age starts at 45 now. not 40. really. logically, i can prove it. but i'm in class...and, like, i found yer LJ through [info]neitherday's, so it's random but only sorta random and i've had too much tea. hi!

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: i explain being tall...
[info]mrciealana
2002-06-13 03:11 pm UTC (link)
Generally I don't explain being tall. Never been asked for an explanation. The only sport I played in college was raquetball. I'm pretty proportional for my height, so it all just works.

Ah great, I'm 6 years from middle age. I feel so much better ;), and I'd kinda guessed about [info]neitherday, since I don't often post about TS issues and you showed up right after...

I haven't had enough tea myself...

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(15 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…